Why Good Lenders Don’t Ask for the Business (And How to Start)

In 30+ years of banking and home lending, including coaching lending teams across the ACT, Illawarra and Riverina, the most common gap I’ve seen in good lenders isn’t product knowledge. It’s the end of a strong appointment: the serviceability numbers work, the client is clearly comfortable, and nobody asks whether they’d like to go ahead.

You’ve had the conversation. The customer’s nodding along, they clearly like what you’re offering, and then… nothing happens. You wrap up the call with a vague “let me know if you have questions” and hope they come back to you. Most of the time, they don’t — not because they weren’t interested, but because you never actually asked.

Asking for the business isn’t about pressure tactics. It’s the one step most salespeople skip out of fear of sounding pushy — and it costs them deals they’d already earned.

You Can’t Ask Until You Know What They Need

Before you can ask for anything, you need to know what problem you’re actually solving. That means asking real, open-ended questions and then genuinely listening to the answers — not waiting for your turn to pitch.

A few questions worth asking every time:

• “What’s prompted you to look at your loan now?”
• “What would a good outcome actually look like for you?”
• “If the numbers work, is there anything that would stop you going ahead?”

These get the customer talking about their own situation in their own words — which tells you far more than any pitch you could give them.

Confidence Isn’t the Same as Pressure

There’s a real difference between asking clearly and pushing hard, and most people who avoid asking are actually just afraid of the second one. You can be direct without being aggressive — the key is respecting that the decision is still theirs, while making it easy for them to say yes.

Empathy and active listening do the heavy lifting here. If you’ve genuinely understood their situation, asking for the business stops feeling like a pitch and starts feeling like the obvious next step.

The Ask Should Feel Like the Next Line

Every conversation should build toward one simple question: “Would you like to go ahead?” If you’ve done the groundwork, this shouldn’t feel like a hard pivot — it should feel like the natural next line.

Timing matters more than most people think. Ask when they’re most engaged — often right after you’ve shown them the borrowing capacity or repayment figure they were hoping for, not three days later in a follow-up email. And tailor how you ask to how they’ve been communicating with you; some people want a straight yes/no question, others want to talk it through first.

Direct Questions Work Better Than Closing Lines

A few lines that move a conversation toward a decision without sounding scripted:

• “Based on what you’ve told me, this sounds like a good fit — does that match how you’re seeing it?”
• “Would it make sense to talk through what this would actually look like for you?”
• “It sounds like this solves the problem you mentioned earlier — where would you like to go from here?”

Notice none of these are a hard close. They’re just honest, direct questions that move things forward.

Most Clients Don’t Say Yes on the First Ask

Most deals don’t close on the first ask, and that’s fine — it’s what you do next that matters. A good follow-up isn’t a nag, it’s a genuine check-in that adds something new each time.

A few things that actually work:

• Set a specific date for the next conversation before you end the current one — don’t leave it open-ended
• Bring something new to each follow-up, even if it’s small — an updated repayment figure, the answer to a policy question they asked, or where their application is up to
• Ask how they’d prefer to be contacted, then actually use that method
• Stay soft — a check-in, not a demand for an answer

Ask Clearly, But Don’t Assume the Yes

Some lenders go the other way and assume the yes, with lines like “when would you like to proceed?” In home lending, I’ve seen that cause more problems than it solves. A home loan is a multi-week process of documentation and underwriting. For most people it’s the biggest financial commitment they’ll ever make. Pushing past their uncertainty doesn’t shorten that process. It moves the hesitation to a later, more expensive stage, often right before settlement, when it’s much harder to unwind.

There’s a responsible lending side too. Our job isn’t just to close the deal. It’s to make sure the client understands and can genuinely afford what they’re signing up for. Assumptive language works against that.

Keep the confidence, but aim it at clarifying a decision, not rushing one. Name the real next step instead of the final outcome: “The next step is getting your payslips across so we can move to formal approval.” Ask what’s still unresolved: “What’s the one thing you’re still not sure about?” Then let the silence sit while they work out whether they can afford the repayment. Asking clearly and assuming the answer are two different things.

What This Means for Any Lending Manager

Asking for the business isn’t a separate skill bolted onto a good sales conversation — it’s the natural end of one. If you’ve genuinely listened, understood the problem, and shown how you solve it, the ask should feel small. The only real mistake is not asking at all.

Written by Michael Wignall, who’s spent 30+ years in banking and home lending across the ACT, Illawarra, and Riverina regions of NSW.

Prefer LinkedIn? I post there first — follow along for the same insights as they go up.

Written by Michael Wignall, Lending Area Manager with 30+ years in banking and home lending across the ACT, Illawarra, and Riverina. Got a question or an idea for a post? Get in touch.