What Actually Works Coaching a Lending Team (Not Another Framework)

I’ve sat through my share of generic coaching frameworks over 30 years in banking — models that read well in a training manual and fall apart the moment a real conversation gets uncomfortable. What actually works with a lending team looks a lot simpler than most coaching theory suggests, and it’s built on a handful of habits I’ve watched genuinely change how a team performs.

Listen for What Isn’t Being Said

A lender who says “the pipeline’s fine” while avoiding eye contact usually means the opposite. The most useful coaching skill I’ve developed isn’t asking better questions — it’s noticing when someone’s answer doesn’t match their tone, and being willing to gently push past the first response to find out what’s actually going on.

Feedback That Names the Actual File, Not the General Pattern

“You need to work on your documentation” helps no one. “That self-employed application last week was missing the BAS statements before it went to underwriting — that’s what added the two-week delay” is something a lender can actually act on next time. Specific, tied to a real file, delivered close to when it happened — that’s the entire difference between feedback that lands and feedback that gets nodded at and forgotten.

Ask Before You Fix

The hardest habit to build in myself, after decades in lending, was resisting the urge to just solve a lender’s problem for them the moment they raised it. “What have you already tried?” or “What’s actually stopping you from doing that?” gets someone thinking through their own situation, rather than handing them my answer and having them forget it by next week.

Match the Person, Not a Formula

Some lenders respond well to being challenged directly. Others shut down under that same approach and need a more collaborative conversation to get to the same place. Applying one coaching style uniformly across a whole team, regardless of who you’re actually talking to, is one of the most common mistakes I’ve seen new managers make.

Track Small Wins When the Environment’s Genuinely Tough

In a market like the current rate cycle, where applications are genuinely harder to close than they were two years ago, waiting for a big win to celebrate can mean waiting a long time. Noticing and naming the smaller wins — a well-handled difficult client conversation, a file that could have gone wrong but didn’t — keeps a team’s confidence intact through a genuinely harder stretch, without pretending the environment hasn’t changed.

The Bottom Line

None of this is complicated in theory. What’s actually hard is doing it consistently — noticing the real signal under a vague answer, giving feedback tied to something specific and recent, and adjusting your approach to the actual person in front of you rather than a framework. That’s the real work of coaching a team well.

Get Blockers and Policy Changes Out in the Open

Coaching only works if the team tells you what is really happening on a file. “It’s progressing” tells me nothing. “It’s stuck waiting on the client’s BAS statements, third follow-up sent Tuesday” tells me exactly where to help. I ask lenders to name the actual blocker every time, and I make it safe to do so. A vague status that sounds fine usually hides a real problem.

Policy changes need the same discipline. A shift in how an income type is assessed, or an update to serviceability buffers, can affect a file that is already halfway through the pipeline. If the news only reaches whoever happened to be in the room, you get inconsistent applications and avoidable rework. This is one area where over-communicating is the safer choice. I make sure everyone hears about it, and I check they understand what it means for their open files.

Both habits are simple. Both stall quietly when nobody owns them. As a manager, I treat them as part of coaching, not admin.

Related Reading

• What 30 Years of Coaching Lending Teams Actually Taught Me
• Managing Teams Through Economic Uncertainty
• Navigating Choppy Waters: Strategies to Find Sales in a Slowing Market

Written by Michael Wignall, who’s spent 30+ years in banking and home lending across the ACT, Illawarra, and Riverina regions of NSW.

More on this topic is collected in the Leadership & Productivity Hub.

Prefer LinkedIn? I post there first — follow along for the same insights as they go up.

Written by Michael Wignall, Lending Area Manager with 30+ years in banking and home lending across the ACT, Illawarra, and Riverina. Got a question or an idea for a post? Get in touch.